People // ClubKid . // Blog
Sunday August 31, 2008 at 11:54 PM |
Hey Indaba Music! how are you?! all i can say to you guys is THANK U SO MUCH FOR THE OPPERTUNITY OF A LIFETIME WITH THE MARIAH CAREY REMIX COMPETITION...
however i do have some things which i have to say in regards to the the voting system... The majority of the particpants could agree with me when i say this... that the voting system method lacks credibility and objectiveness... The top remixers who will make the final are will be there because some of them actually do have talent and deserve to be there 100%.. whilst other remixers have, as user "FB cool" explains "EXPERT SPAMMING" skills and 'popularity' amongst other users, which will then cause them to be higher up than the more talented remixers! I know that going through 2000 mixes is a daunting and difficult task our three great judges, however, i know that there are more than 10 remixes in the remixing pile which all contain the three main remix aspects: Marketability, Originality, and Creativity. - and there are some which dont covour all the three grounds.
If you could consider changing the voting rules to make it more objective instead of subjective as it seems now... that would be sooo excellent. It would also be a fair game... thank you for your time.
ClubKid
Digg this
del.icio.usMonday September 01, 2008 at 02:42 AM
totally agree !
A suggestion to resolve the problem for the next contest :
close the external vote, only indaba users or new subscritions !
then voters who voted for the winner could win A.D points !
showing that they have a good nose (or not) about who will win, who is the best adequat remix ! displayed like an "Art Director" gauge ! (it's also a way to attract real art directors)<-quality, good way for them to improve credibility and for label company to recrut the best of them !
A user with a big "art director" gauge have much more credibility that someone who always goes wrong in his choices.
A top 20 of the best "art directors" can be displayed on indaba page ! <- popularity interest !
to increase interest, those points can give to users more free space, or bandwith or a specific advantage to define.
I was just a track ...
But waiting and hoping that the votes would be more realistics
please
Vote for clubkid remix, his remix diserve to be in the top 10 as well as mine ;-) I mean it !
so vote please for his remix
http://www.indabamusic.com/submissions/show/2819
and mine too
http://www.indabamusic.com/submissions/show/2818
FB (aka Neo fighting against the matrix)
Log in to comment on this blog post
